
Hallowe'en seems like the one day of the year when everything comes right. I'm not bothered about the consumer exploitation of All Hallows Eve; I simply feel like I've joined the consensus reality around me when the shops are full of plastic spiders, cobweb-themed outfits and fake blood. Or maybe the consensus reality has joined in with me.
But it bothers me that I keep hearing complaints that the UK is experiencing the Americanisation of Hallowe'en through the trick or treat phenomenon. The practice of children dressing up and going door to door is traditional in Scotland and Ireland, and some parts of the north of England too. In Scotland it was traditional for children to go guising, which means wearing a disguise and calling on your neighbours, doing a simple turn such a reciting a poem or performing a card trick or some small entertainment. In my day this had slightly degenerated, in some cases, into telling a joke - well at least it's a form of entertainment. These guisers were then rewarded with apples, nuts, a few sweets or a few coins. This tradition was completely unknown in most parts of England and Wales.
Now I understand that the objection to trick or treaters comes from good people questioning whether they should be held-up by small pirates on their own door steps, demanding "candy". Well, I recognise the individual right to a curmudgeonly "Humbug!" so I'll say nothing. How would it be instead if impoverished children appeared at your door saying prayers for the souls of your dead relatives? And in response you could give them a soul cake, the eating of which freed your loved-one's soul from purgatory, as was traditional in parts of Britain from Medieval times. No transatlantic invasion there.
For myself I'm happy to see kids dress as zombies and go round the neighbourhood in a state of sugar-fuelled intoxication. It's imaginative, it's outdoors and it's better than Nintendo Wii.
Pictured above is the maginficent Myrna Loy.














